Flatiron & NoMad Thanksgiving Dining Guide 2023

This year, enjoy Thanksgiving with family and friends at a local restaurant offering prix-fixe menus and specials. Planning to stay in? Show some love to your favorite eateries by ordering a Thanksgiving meal kit or dessert for your gathering. Reservations will fill up quickly so book your tables as early as possible.

In-Person Dining

Barbounia, 250 Park Avenue South, (212) 995-0242, Reservations, @barbounianyc
Treat your loved ones to a Mediterranean Thanksgiving with Barbounia’s three-course prix fixe menu at $91 per person.

Bazár Tapas Bar and Restaurant, 31 West 26th Street, (212) 510-8155, Reservations, @bazartapasnyc
At Bazár Tapas, celebrate with a three-course prix fixe menu featuring Thanksgiving Paella and more delicious dishes. $85 per person.

BLACKBARN, 19 East 26th Street, (212) 265-5959, Reservations, @blackbarnrestaurant
Enjoy Thanksgiving at the farm-to-table restaurant, BLACKBARN, with a three-course prix fixe menu. Appetizers and sides served family style, mains and desserts individually plated at $110 for adults and $55 for children under 12.

The Churchill Tavern, 45 East 28th Street, (646) 922-7744, Reservations, @thechurchillnyc
For Thanksgiving, The Churchill Tavern will be serving a special menu with appetizers, entrees, a selection of trimmings, and desserts.

COTE Korean Steakhouse, 16 West 22nd Street, (212) 401-7986, Reservations, @cote_nyc
Celebrate at Michelin-starred COTE with a Thanksgiving Feast featuring premium steak cuts with savory accompaniments at $155 per person. Seatings are available from 1 – 9 pm on Thanksgiving Day.

The Gallery by odo, 17 West 20th Street, (917) 454-8095, Reservations, @the.gallery.nyc
Indulge in a Thanksgiving prix-fixe menu at Michelin-starred The Gallery by Odo featuring an extensive all-you-can-eat Kushiage selection. $85 per person.

Gramercy Tavern, 42 East 20th Street, (212) 477-0777, Reservations, @gramercytavern
The Michelin-starred New American restaurant is offering a three-course prix fixe menu from 11 am – 7 pm on Thanksgiving Day in The Tavern and The Dining Room. The bar will be open all day serving an a la carte menu. $195 per person, $85 for children under 12. Maximum party size is 8 guests.

Hill Country Barbecue Market, 30 West 26th Street, (212) 255-4544, Reservations, @hillcountrybbq
Enjoy a Texas-sized Thanksgiving Feast at Hill Country with 90-minute seatings starting at 12 pm, 2 pm, 4 pm, and 6 pm. Highlights include pit-smoked turkey, signature barbecue, classic sides, and desserts. $95 for adults, $45 for children ages 5 – 12, and free for kids under 5.

Il Fiorista, 17 West 26th Street, (646) 490-8240, Reservations, @ilfioristanyc
Have a floral-inspired Thanksgiving featuring floral elements in starters, mains, and cocktails.

Flatiron Room, 37 West 26th Street, (212) 725-3860, @theflatironroom_nomad
Celebrate Thanksgiving at the popular whiskey bar and live jazz lounge. The Flatiron Room is offering a four-course prix fixe menu with seatings at 2 pm, 4:30 pm, 7 pm, and 9:30 pm. $135 per person.

ilili, 236 Fifth Avenue, (212) 683-2929, Reservations, @ililirestaurants
Spend Thanksgiving at Lebanese-Mediterranean restaurant, ilili, with a three-course prix fixe menu. $135 for adults and $50 for kids under 12. Catering is also available.

Isabelle’s Osteria, 245 Park Avenue South, (212) 388-1145, Reservations, @isabellesnyc
Celebrate Thanksgiving at contemporary Italian restaurant, Isabelle’s Osteria, offering a three-course prix fixe menu for $75 per person.

John Doe Craft Bar & Kitchen, 253 Fifth Avenue, (646) 882-4007, @johndoenyc
Spend Thanksgiving with loved ones at John Doe Craft Bar & Kitchen and enjoy a three-course prix fixe menu including starts, mains, and desserts.

Koloman, 16 West 29th Street, (212) 790-8970, Reservations, @kolomannyc
French-Viennese restaurant, Koloman, is offering Thanksgiving this year with a prix fixe menu, including a duet of venison, slow roasted turkey, and traditional pumpkin pie. $165 per person. Wine pairing available. Also, cater your feast at home with Koloman’s to-go meal kit featuring a whole roasted turkey, classic holiday sides, and pumpkin pie. Available for pickup on Wednesday, November 22nd. Serves 4 – 6 people. Call or email to place your order.

L’Amico, 849 Sixth Avenue, (212) 201-4065, Reservations, @lamiconyc
L’Amico is celebrating Thanksgiving with a three-course prix fixe menu including appetizers, entrees, and dessert from 11:30 am – 9 pm. $98 per person. Wine pairing available.

La Pecora Bianca, 1133 Broadway, (212) 498-9696, Reservations, @lapecorabianca
Have an Italian-inspired Thanksgiving at La Pecora Bianca offering a three-course prix fixe menu. $70 per person.

Lupetto, 1123 Broadway, (212) 547-8750, Reservations,@lupettonyc
Join the newly opened wood-fired Italian steakhouse for Thanksgiving. From 4pm – 9pm on Thanksgiving Day enjoy their full menu, plus a special holiday favorite.

Mamazul, 1155 Broadway, (212) 500-6988, Reservations, @mamazulnyc
Celebrate Thanksgiving at Mexican restaurant Mamazul with a three-course prix fixe menu. $75 per person.

Oscar Wilde NYC, 45 West 27th Street, (212) 213-3066, Reservations, @oscarwildenyc
The Victorian-style bistro is offering Traditional Thanksgiving Dinner Plates that include roasted turkey and all of your favorite sides. $45 per person.

Rezdôra, 27 East 20th Street, (646) 692-9090, Reservations, @rezdoranyc
Enjoy Thanksgiving at Michelin-starred Northern Italian restaurant, Rezdôra, with a six-course prix fixe menu. 

Sarabeth’s, 381 Park Avenue South, (212) 335-0093, Reservations, @sarabethsnyc
Sarabeth’s is offering a four-course prix fixe menu for Thanksgiving from 2 – 9 pm. $85 per adult and $38 per child. To-go Thanksgiving dinners are also available.

Scarpetta, 88 Madison Avenue, (212) 691-0555, Reservations, @scarpettarestaurants
Celebrate at Scarpetta of LDV Hospitality for Thanksgiving with a four-course prix fixe menu at $140 per person.

The Smith, 1150 Broadway, (212) 685-4500, Reservations, @thesmithrestaurant
Enjoy a three-course Thanksgiving dinner menu at The Smith with fixings included for the table. $78 per person.

Zaytinya, 1185 Broadway, (332) 249-8160, Reservations, @zaytinya
Mediterranean restaurant Zaytinya at The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad will be offering Thanksgiving specials from Wednesday, November 22nd through Sunday, November 26th including, butternut squash hummus, fall vegetable horiatiki, and turkey kleftico. $85 per person.

To-Go Dining

Eataly, 200 Fifth Avenue, (212) 229-2560, Order, @eatalynewyorkcity
Eataly is offering turkeys from Pat LaFrieda and KellyBronze. KellyBronze turkey pre-orders are available until November 12th and Pat LaFrieda turkey pre-orders are available until November 21st.

Mangia NYC, 22 West 23rd Street, (212) 647-0200, Order, @mangia_nyc_official
Cater your Thanksgiving dinner at-home with Mangia NYC. Served family-style for a minimum of 6 people. The menu includes starters, entrees, sides, and desserts. All prices per person.

Mark’s Off Madison, 41 Madison Avenue, (646) 838-8300, @marksoffmadison
Mark’s Off Madison is offering Thanksgiving Dinner Catering. Menu includes appetizers, mains, sides, and desserts. Orders must be placed by Monday, November 20th at 5 pm for pickup on Wednesday, November 22nd between 1 – 9 pm. To place your order, email your filled out order form here.

Desserts

Bourke Street Bakery, 15 East 28th Street, (718) 744-4803, Order, @bourkestreetbakerynyc
Order some tasty baked goods from Bourke Street Bakery for your Thanksgiving gathering, including an Apple Cider Crumble Pie, Chocolate Pecan Pie, and Pumpkin Pie.

Dominique Ansel Workshop, 17 East 27th Street, (212) 901-1015, Order, @dominiqueanselworkshop
Serve a beautiful pie from Dominique Ansel Workshop for Thanksgiving. Options include, Extra Silky Pumpkin Pie, Bourbon Pecan Pie, and Salted Caramel Apple Pie. Pre-order for pickup between Tuesday, November 21st through Thursday, November 23rd.

Krispy Kreme, 36 East 23rd Street, (315) 203-7058, Order, @krispykreme
Krispy Kreme has released their Flavors of Fall Doughnut Collection for Thanksgiving this year. Featured doughnuts include, Caramel Pecan Brownie, Classic Blackberry Crisp Filled, Cinnamon Latte Lover, Spiced Apple Filled, Chocolate Iced with Autumn Sprinkles, and Pumpkin Spice Cake.

Lady M Confections, 1178 Broadway, (212) 452-2222, Order, @ladymcakes
Enjoy Lady M’s Pumpkin Brûlée Mille Crêpes featuring layers of handmade crepes filled with vanilla pumpkin pastry cream and pumpkin purée.

Lysée, 44 East 21st Street, Order, @lysee.nyc
Korean and French-inspired pastry boutique Lysée is offering a Pecan Tart with Salted Vanilla Cream for Thanksgiving. Pre-order for pickup from November 15th – November 26th.

maman, 22 West 25th Street, (646) 476-7660, Order, @_mamannyc_
French-American cafe maman is offering delicious pies for Thanksgiving. Pre-order your pies until November 19th via email.

Milk Bar, 1196 Broadway, (347) 974-4975, Order, @milkbarstore
Serve decadent desserts from Milk Bar at your gathering. Thanksgiving desserts include, Pumpkin Milk Bar Pie, Pumpkin Coffee-Cake Cake, Pumpkin Coffee-Cake Cake Truffles, and Caramel Apple Cake.

Tarallucci e Vino NoMad, 44 East 28th Street, (212) 779-1100, Order, @taralluccinyc
Have seasonal, made-to-order pies for Thanksgiving from Tarallucci e Vino NoMad. Pie offerings include, Apple Crumb, Original Pumpkin, Ricotta-Chocolate, Torta Della Nonna, and Pear-Chocolate. $34 each. Orders must be placed by 6 pm for next day pickup.

Header & Thumbnail Photo Credit: BLACKBARN